Carolyn is an atheist that appeared in "Love, Blactually". She dated Brian for three weeks after they met in a bookstore. Brian allowed Stewie to talk him into resisting sex with Carol until she finally left him for Cleveland, believing that Brian only wanted friendship. When Cleveland considered marrying Carol, Cleveland's ex-wife Loretta Brown asked him to come back to her but he turned her down. Cleveland returned to find Carol then cheating on him with Quagmire. Cleveland later found out that she gave him genital warts.

In "Valentine's Day in Quahog", Stewie gathers scores of Brian’s former girlfriends including Carolyn to get to the bottom of why he’s unsuccessful in love.

She is voiced by Kat Foster.