Toby is Meg's date in "Valentine's Day in Quahog". They met online and dated briefly before Toby gave Meg a drink that caused her to faint. When Meg woke up in a hotel, it was revealed that Toby knocked her out in order to steal her kidney. However, since Toby promised to spend the day with her, they continued their date. At the end, Toby returned Meg's kidney.